top of page

Is pro-choice 'pro-violence?' Part 1

Category:

Culture

Sub-category:

Violence

Supporting abortion as a matter of “choice” does not negate the fact that abortion involves acts that meet the ordinary definition of violence. Violence is not defined by whether the victim is valued, conscious, or granted rights; it is defined by the use of physical force that harms a living being. People readily recognize violence against animals without first resolving debates about their moral status or cognitive capacities. Kicking a squirrel or striking a bird with a rock is understood as violence simply because a living being is physically harmed.


The same logic applies to the unborn. There is no serious dispute that the unborn are biologically distinct, living members of the species Homo sapiens. Recognizing that they can be victims of violence does not require settling philosophical questions about personhood or comparing their value to that of born humans or animals. Even if someone believes unborn humans are less valuable than dogs or insects, that belief does not change whether violent force is being used against them.


At different stages of pregnancy, abortion procedures involve suffocation, dismemberment, the draining of blood, or the intentional stopping of the fetus’s life through lethal injection or stabbing. These actions are violent by their nature. Labeling abortion as “choice” reframes who is empowered to decide, but it does not alter what is physically done. If violence is defined by the intentional use of force that destroys or seriously harms a living being, then abortion fits that description regardless of the moral conclusions one ultimately draws.

Key Takeaways

  • Violence does not depend on personhood or value; it depends on the use of physical force that harms a living being.


  • The unborn are biologically living human organisms, making them possible victims of violence regardless of how they are ranked morally.


  • Abortion procedures involve acts—suffocation, dismemberment, lethal injection—that are inherently violent by ordinary standards.


  • Calling abortion a “choice” changes the framing, not the physical reality of what is done to the unborn.

bottom of page